Like you, I learned with dismay of the existence of Jcall petition addressed to the European Union to put pressure on Israel to accept a "reasonable solution to the conflict." We expressed that signatures as famous and prestigious as those of Bernard-Henri Levy, Alain Finkielkraut, Boris Cyrulnique, George Benson, personalities deemed "Zionists" were affixed to that call. This has added to our outrage. Below, the letter I wrote to their attention.
Signatories Jcall,
You can not ask you do not have the approach you take on the situation in Israel, but what right have you, Jewish intellectuals, you send to the European Union to put pressure on us? We assume that life in Israel and that all it requires and also brings us. None of you is willing to pay the price for being Israeli, and you ask the nations of Europe to give us the power struggle for us to impose the solution that you feel the most reasonable, under the pretext that you love Israel? I do not question that you think will the good of Israel, but when you say you love Israel, I doubt it. It is also love Israel to respect the people of this country in all its diversity of opinions and backgrounds, and also his choice. Love Israel, it is not confined in this country what it was like everything in there Participant no other.
You tell me that many people in Israel think like you signed Jcall. It is quite true, but the debate is not about the merits of the formula for resolving the conflict that you advocate in this appeal. So yes, between us, Jews of all persuasions, we can, we must talk and discuss these things. The question is not based on the debate or not debate us. This debate exists, it is very stormy, but this is not what is questioned here.
The question is: How "Jewish" speaking, you do you believe in moral position to send you the Nations for us to pressure, and thereby cancel what the people of this country and all its components decides for himself? " If indeed you consider yourself still part of this people, the Jewish people. As a good Hebrew, in an attitude of Jewish consciousness is virtually treason to serve you goyim to force our hand. ( goyim in Hebrew meaning "nations" and not "non-Jews"). As if the UN were only waiting for you to give them the green light to press? Virtually all the solutions and actions we take in recent decades we have imposed on the forceps by foreign pressure.
The implications of your signatures on this appeal are very serious. Your initiative means the eyes of the world that the Jews of Israel are unable to decide for themselves and their system of deliberation by public debate and election in the Israeli society has no value in itself. In other words the state of Israel is a political fiction. How to intellectuals as brilliant, who can consider the implications of their stance, it could he escape? I tend to believe that it could not not escape and that certify your arrogance toward the Israelis "dowdy" and "uncouth" we are your eyes.
Apart from the indigestible contempt and condescension of such an attitude, it means that the Jewish people is still not ready to be ruler of his destiny on the earth, and therefore he is still unfit to Independence National. That's what this lead your signatures on the appeal Jcall. You signed, you bring the people of Israel to its situation prior to May 14, 1948, before the Declaration of Independence of the State of Israel by David Ben-Gurion. That is to say to a reality in which the Jewish people must be sponsored by the nations of the world, by a British mandate or "Obama" and where decisions concerning are made elsewhere, by others at the UN, the "machine". A situation where the Jewish people are relegated to the stadium lobbyist Jewish community. In other words, the concepts of sovereignty, government, nation, are not applicable for the Jewish people in Israel. It also claims that the Arab-Muslim world, but it's another debate. The convergence of attitudes, however, that a priori nothing to do with each other, could not but be relieved.
That post that Zionism is nothing but anti-Zionism recycled! The Jewish people can only be a fragmented cluster people organized in communities scattered preaching God knows what Jewish values. The best intentions would be willing to grant the "Jewish Community of Palestine," a kind of administrative autonomy and let have a self-defense militia, but for major decisions, it is others who must take. In our case, you Jewish intellectuals in exile in consultation with leaders of nations that scaffold the territorial and geopolitical conditions of existence in Hebrew that we are indigenous.
Signatories Jcall,
You can not ask you do not have the approach you take on the situation in Israel, but what right have you, Jewish intellectuals, you send to the European Union to put pressure on us? We assume that life in Israel and that all it requires and also brings us. None of you is willing to pay the price for being Israeli, and you ask the nations of Europe to give us the power struggle for us to impose the solution that you feel the most reasonable, under the pretext that you love Israel? I do not question that you think will the good of Israel, but when you say you love Israel, I doubt it. It is also love Israel to respect the people of this country in all its diversity of opinions and backgrounds, and also his choice. Love Israel, it is not confined in this country what it was like everything in there Participant no other.
You tell me that many people in Israel think like you signed Jcall. It is quite true, but the debate is not about the merits of the formula for resolving the conflict that you advocate in this appeal. So yes, between us, Jews of all persuasions, we can, we must talk and discuss these things. The question is not based on the debate or not debate us. This debate exists, it is very stormy, but this is not what is questioned here.
The question is: How "Jewish" speaking, you do you believe in moral position to send you the Nations for us to pressure, and thereby cancel what the people of this country and all its components decides for himself? " If indeed you consider yourself still part of this people, the Jewish people. As a good Hebrew, in an attitude of Jewish consciousness is virtually treason to serve you goyim to force our hand. ( goyim in Hebrew meaning "nations" and not "non-Jews"). As if the UN were only waiting for you to give them the green light to press? Virtually all the solutions and actions we take in recent decades we have imposed on the forceps by foreign pressure.
The implications of your signatures on this appeal are very serious. Your initiative means the eyes of the world that the Jews of Israel are unable to decide for themselves and their system of deliberation by public debate and election in the Israeli society has no value in itself. In other words the state of Israel is a political fiction. How to intellectuals as brilliant, who can consider the implications of their stance, it could he escape? I tend to believe that it could not not escape and that certify your arrogance toward the Israelis "dowdy" and "uncouth" we are your eyes.
Apart from the indigestible contempt and condescension of such an attitude, it means that the Jewish people is still not ready to be ruler of his destiny on the earth, and therefore he is still unfit to Independence National. That's what this lead your signatures on the appeal Jcall. You signed, you bring the people of Israel to its situation prior to May 14, 1948, before the Declaration of Independence of the State of Israel by David Ben-Gurion. That is to say to a reality in which the Jewish people must be sponsored by the nations of the world, by a British mandate or "Obama" and where decisions concerning are made elsewhere, by others at the UN, the "machine". A situation where the Jewish people are relegated to the stadium lobbyist Jewish community. In other words, the concepts of sovereignty, government, nation, are not applicable for the Jewish people in Israel. It also claims that the Arab-Muslim world, but it's another debate. The convergence of attitudes, however, that a priori nothing to do with each other, could not but be relieved.
That post that Zionism is nothing but anti-Zionism recycled! The Jewish people can only be a fragmented cluster people organized in communities scattered preaching God knows what Jewish values. The best intentions would be willing to grant the "Jewish Community of Palestine," a kind of administrative autonomy and let have a self-defense militia, but for major decisions, it is others who must take. In our case, you Jewish intellectuals in exile in consultation with leaders of nations that scaffold the territorial and geopolitical conditions of existence in Hebrew that we are indigenous.
That is what leads your initiative. That's what you say in clear Obama, Putin, Sarkozy, Gordon Brown, Angela Merkel and shock wave, as the nazislamism Ahmanidjad, Assad and other Arab and Muslim tyrants hairpieces that are waiting when to exterminate us. In meetings with the departments strategic assessment of the Syrian and Iranian war, your diatribes can only encourage them. Me in their shoes, I rubbed my hands in satisfaction: "Jews prominent and renowned" solidarity with Israel "are pressuring the international community to the State of Israel complies with foreign diktat. "Very strong your initiative!
Does the fact that you're all still mired in an existential reality of exile would have to do with this drift? I would not go that far, but c is worse. Without going into this debate too, I would say that it is mainly the fact that you do not intend to link your destiny, your fate, your existence to that of Israel, the people and its state in any future.
This initiative is therefore not only be a disagreement or a mere political controversy between you and us. If it were only that, either. For us, it is in the worst case a tragedy more, but for you it is a tragedy. Why a tragedy? Because you are demonstrating thereby that the fate of Israel ultimately must be decided elsewhere, by others, not by the Jews of Israel. That's the worst mistakes of identity that we can commit to oneself as a Jew. This implies ipso facto put you outside of the Jewish people. It is also not the first time this has happened in our history. This is not my sentence you to whatever it is you who you are yourself condemned to put you off, that your destiny forks from that of our entire people, Israel and in exile for whom Israel is the anchor and its identity, for which the Land of Israel is the house and not just an idea. Maybe because you have not thought through the implications of this option cosmopolitanism that is roughly the choice of identity common to all of you signed?
Does the fact that you're all still mired in an existential reality of exile would have to do with this drift? I would not go that far, but c is worse. Without going into this debate too, I would say that it is mainly the fact that you do not intend to link your destiny, your fate, your existence to that of Israel, the people and its state in any future.
This initiative is therefore not only be a disagreement or a mere political controversy between you and us. If it were only that, either. For us, it is in the worst case a tragedy more, but for you it is a tragedy. Why a tragedy? Because you are demonstrating thereby that the fate of Israel ultimately must be decided elsewhere, by others, not by the Jews of Israel. That's the worst mistakes of identity that we can commit to oneself as a Jew. This implies ipso facto put you outside of the Jewish people. It is also not the first time this has happened in our history. This is not my sentence you to whatever it is you who you are yourself condemned to put you off, that your destiny forks from that of our entire people, Israel and in exile for whom Israel is the anchor and its identity, for which the Land of Israel is the house and not just an idea. Maybe because you have not thought through the implications of this option cosmopolitanism that is roughly the choice of identity common to all of you signed?
So of course, all openings in return, repentance would be said in religious language, may be possible. Although this is not religion it is, it's much more serious and critical than that. So it's not reading the Psalms or adopting attitudes of pious hypocrisy of one would say in French, it is repaired.
But I feel that this message is inaudible to you, see incomprehensible, because I speak Jewish even though I say it in French, and you, you speak French, even when you're talking about a Jew. This probably growing gap long time and we do acknowledge that now. A gap may become impassable, like last week when the air links could not be between Israel and Europe precisely during the festivities of Yom Ha'atzmaut , the Independence Day of Israel - we people of Israel in Israel as a nation linked to its Earth on one side, and you cook up this call in with the rest of Nations. This is not new in the very long history of Israel. Besides these things, it reads and it is studied. Meir Ben-
Hayoun
But I feel that this message is inaudible to you, see incomprehensible, because I speak Jewish even though I say it in French, and you, you speak French, even when you're talking about a Jew. This probably growing gap long time and we do acknowledge that now. A gap may become impassable, like last week when the air links could not be between Israel and Europe precisely during the festivities of Yom Ha'atzmaut , the Independence Day of Israel - we people of Israel in Israel as a nation linked to its Earth on one side, and you cook up this call in with the rest of Nations. This is not new in the very long history of Israel. Besides these things, it reads and it is studied. Meir Ben-
Hayoun
According to information received by the Director of Interior Security Service (Shabak) Mr. Yuval Diskin at his press conference, Pfc 
The Director of Shabak added that these documents were of various kinds: orders covert Command Center and Staff, the army of devices in an emergency, deployment of units, scenarios of engagement, doctrine and tactics many other things. Therefore, disclose such information may seriously endanger soldiers and Israeli civilians. 
Two months later, in December 2009, Anat Kam was apprehended and questioned, and since she is under house arrest. On January 14, 2010, she was indicted for espionage. 
